While Bimini and Barbados have always appealed to me, Bonaire is renowned for its diving. I would love to have my brothers see Stingray City in Grand Cayman. The Virgin Islands - US and British - are enticing, and I am fascinated by Trinidad and Tobago, too. Not to mention Hawaii. The October issue of Sport Diver features an interesting article about the Dominican Republic, so I can now add that to my list of places to see someday.
So many islands, so little time.